Back home

Proof

713 votes

Producing House

Catherine is a woman in her late twenties who is strongly devoted to her father, Robert, a brilliant and well-known mathematician whose grip on reality is beginning to slip away. As Robert descends into madness, Catherine begins to wonder if she may have inherited her father's mental illness along with his mathematical genius.

movie

Status: Released

Released Date: 2005-09-05

Runtime: 101 mins

Director: John Madden

Spoken language: English

Genres: Drama, Mystery

Original title: Proof

Production Companies: Miramax, Endgame Entertainment, Hart-Sharp Entertainment

Production Countries: United States of America

Reviews

G

Geronimo1967
This film quite succinctly sums up the characteristics of it's principal character. At times it's potent and at others it's a mess. It's all about "Catherine" (Gwyneth Paltrow) who together with her sister "Claire" (Hope Davis) are the daughters of acclaimed mathematician "Robert" (Sir Anthony Hopkins). Now he was borderline obsessed, in a clinical fashion, with his work writing a proof that will profoundly redefine thinking amongst his scientific community. Thing is, he's dead now and seems determined to "haunt" the life of his just as determined daughter (Paltrow) who, herself, treads a very thin line between reality and fantasy. Matters are exacerbated when one of his star pupils "Hal" (Jake Gyllenhaal) asks to look through their late father's papers and discovers something of monumental importance. Who wrote this, though - father or child or both? As the intensity grows for both sisters, their mental stability and their relationship is severely tested whilst the observing "Hal" (now the boyfriend of "Catherine") looks on somewhat dazed and confused as to what to do next as the narrative becomes increasingly peppered with historical familial flashbacks. Paltrow manages quite well with what must have been a difficult part and Davis does likewise as the loving sister who does not/did not share the all-consuming compulsion of her sibling and her dad. Some of the scenes between the two quite compellingly illustrate just how frustrations were growing as 'Catherine" seems bent on a slippery slope to depression. Gyllenhaal hasn't very much to work with and isn't really much more than eye candy and with the odd intervention from Sir Anthony adding little meat to the bones, there's not really enough to hold the film together consistently. It relies too much on the emotionally turbulent aspects of their persona and fails to deliver well on the rationale of their fixation. Just what is this proof and what does it mean to ordinary people - a question frequently asked by "Claire", too.
2024-07-18

t

tmdb28039023
Math is an exact science. A mathematical proof is a demonstration of this exactness. Math can also be, according to those who study it, beautiful – an art form even; in that sense, Proof is an aptly titled film in which mathematics overlaps with metaphysics, poetry and even faith. Proof knows its characters’ field well enough to have a little fun with it (a character and his math department buddies have a band, and once of their songs is called “i”, as in ‘imaginary number;’ “They just stand there. They don't play anything for three minutes.”); on the other hand, it assumes at times, not entirely without reason, ignorance on the part of the audience. Now, I’ll confess that I didn’t know what a Germain prime was, but the characters do, so it’s a bit of awkward exposition when one explains it to another. Other than this, director John Madden truly lucked out with this movie – which is not to say he didn’t have anything at all to do with the success of the material –; in addition to being based on a Pulitzer Prize-winning play, you simply can’t go wrong when you only have four characters and three of them are played by Hopkins, Gyllenhaal, and Paltrow.
2022-08-27

Recommendations

Flora
2

Flora

2017-04-27

In 1929, an expedition of university botanists enter an uncharted forest where they discover, and mu

Im Tunnel
2

Im Tunnel

2017-04-24

After Maren's brother is murdered, the young woman is completely shaken. Because the police only dea

Erotic Tales
0.9

Erotic Tales

1980-06-25

Three women are secretly plush prostitutes. They are successively called by a mysterious person to h

Twelve Monkeys
3.8

Twelve Monkeys

1995-12-29

In the year 2035, convict James Cole reluctantly volunteers to be sent back in time to discover the

Dirty Dancing
3.6

Dirty Dancing

1987-08-21

Expecting the usual tedium that accompanies a summer in the Catskills with her family, 17-year-old F

Blind Chance
3.8

Blind Chance

1987-01-10

Witek runs after a train. Three variations follow on how such a seemingly banal incident could influ

Donnie Darko
3.9

Donnie Darko

2001-01-19

After narrowly escaping a bizarre accident, a troubled teenager is plagued by visions of a large bun

Belle Époque
3.3

Belle Époque

1992-12-04

In 1931, a young soldier deserts from the army and falls into a country farm, where he is welcomed b

The Mothman Prophecies
3.1

The Mothman Prophecies

2002-01-25

Reporter John Klein is plunged into a world of impossible terror and unthinkable chaos when fate dra

Hard Candy
3.4

Hard Candy

2005-01-14

Hayley’s a smart, charming teenage girl. Jeff’s a handsome, smooth fashion photographer. An Internet

In the Mouth of Madness
3.6

In the Mouth of Madness

1995-02-03

An insurance investigator visits a small town while looking into the strange disappearance of a popu

Dark City
3.7

Dark City

1998-02-27

A man struggles with memories of his past, including a wife he cannot remember, in a nightmarish wor

Signs
3.4

Signs

2002-08-02

A family living on a farm finds mysterious crop circles in their fields which suggests something mor

Sneakers
3.5

Sneakers

1992-09-09

When shadowy U.S. intelligence agents blackmail a reformed computer hacker and his eccentric team of

Reign Over Me
3.6

Reign Over Me

2007-03-22

A man who lost his family in the September 11 attack on New York City runs into his old college room

Sicko
3.7

Sicko

2007-05-18

A documentary about the corrupt health care system in The United States who's main goal is to make p

The Witness
0

The Witness

1969-01-01

Cécile teaches English at the Collegium in Bruges. She has a boyfriend, Thomas, a student at the Bea

The Country Girl
3.5

The Country Girl

1954-12-15

An actor on the skids is given one more chance to regain his stardom, as well as his self-respect, y

Into the Fire
2.6

Into the Fire

2005-09-23

Into the Fire follows the story of Walter Hartwig, a lieutenant in the New York City Harbor Unit, wh

Pieces of a Woman
3.5

Pieces of a Woman

2020-12-30

When a young mother's home birth ends in unfathomable tragedy, she begins a year-long odyssey of mou