Back home

All We Imagine as Light

189 votes

Producing House

In Mumbai, Nurse Prabha's routine is troubled when she receives an unexpected gift from her estranged husband. Her younger roommate, Anu, tries in vain to find a spot in the city to be intimate with her boyfriend. A trip to a beach town allows them to find a space for their desires to manifest.

movie

Status: Released

Released Date: 2024-09-21

Runtime: 118 mins

Director: Payal Kapadia

Writer: Payal Kapadia

Spoken language: हिन्दी, Deutsch, English, ,

Genres: Drama, Romance

Original title: All We Imagine as Light

Production Companies: petit chaos, Chalk and Cheese, ARTE France Cinéma, BALDR Film, Another Birth, Les Films Fauves, Pulpa Film

Production Countries: India, France, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Italy

Reviews

B

Brent_Marchant
Invariably, there’s always one film release each year that’s vastly and inexplicably overrated, both in terms of critical acclaim and awards season recognition, and this disappointing, tediously paced slog tops my list of candidates for 2024. Writer-director Payal Kapadia’s examination of contemporary working class conditions in Mumbai follows the stories of three women who struggle with getting by financially, vocationally and personally, all of them having relocated to the city from their rural roots in search of illusory, overpromised opportunities. The picture has been widely praised for its gentle treatment of its subject, along with its sensitive and nuanced handling of its principals’ lives. To me, however, this is a politely euphemistic way of saying it’s boring (I can’t recall how many times I checked my watch during the screening I attended). Moreover, this offering tries unsuccessfully to cover too much ground (and not very well at that), including an array of topics ranging from loneliness to fiscal hardship to gentrification to outmoded traditions and more. I also don’t find this offering to be especially groundbreaking in terms of its subject matter; its themes of working class struggles and personal isolation, in my estimation, are addressed far more effectively in other Indian films like “The Lunchbox” (2013) and “Fire in the Mountains” (2021), which present more compelling and more engaging treatments of their stories (watch those pictures instead). On top of all this, there are some narrative elements that don’t feel sufficiently fleshed out or that are either implausible or woefully executed surrealistically (it’s subtlety often makes it hard to tell which is truly the case). Admittedly, the film’s aesthetics, such as its cinematography, have much going for them, but they’re not nearly enough to make up for the picture’s larger and more significant shortcomings. At the risk of being ridiculed, I truly don’t believe “All We Imagine as Light” is rightfully worthy of the many accolades it has received from the Golden Globe Awards, the Critics Choice Awards, the Independent Spirit Awards, the National Board of Review, and the Cannes and Chicago Film Festivals, among others. With so many other (and better) international film offerings out there, it’s regrettable that these competitions and festivals have squandered nominations and awards on this needlessly hyped undercooked release.
2024-12-16

g

griggs79
_All We Imagine as Light_, a visually delicate exploration of intimacy, displacement, and the quiet search for connection, has earned the prestigious Grand Prix at Cannes. Set in Mumbai, the film follows the lives of three women working in a hospital as they navigate the complexities of their personal lives and fleeting moments of closeness. The film's serene atmosphere, like a gentle breeze, and ethereal cinematography create a meditative mood that resonates deeply with viewers seeking emotional introspection. Despite its accolades, _All We Imagine as Light_ feels more like a familiar echo than a groundbreaking work. It thrives on its quiet pacing and understated performances but leans heavily on well-trodden narratives. The story explores a short-lived, transformative period in people's lives without providing clear resolutions. While this might appeal to slower, more reflective cinema fans, it risks leaving others feeling they've seen this narrative too many times before. The film's lack of emotional depth can make its drawn-out pace seem unnecessary, leading some to question whether its ambiguous ending is an artistic choice or a narrative flaw. At times, _All We Imagine as Light_ feels ephemeral—beautiful, yes, but fleeting and ultimately unsatisfying. Exploring a few months in each character's life is compelling, but the film struggles to find new angles on the well-worn theme of the void of human connection. The performances, though strong, need to elevate the material more to make it stand out as extraordinary. Kani Kusruti, Divya Prabha, and Chhaya Kadam bring authenticity to their roles. Still, their characters don't grow beyond their archetypes—estranged lovers, lonely workers, and outsiders searching for meaning. Ultimately, _All We Imagine as Light_ is a pleasant but slightly disappointing film. It lingers in the memory, not because it profoundly moves you but because it leaves you wondering if you've seen this story in another movie—perhaps better executed. It's a pleasant watch, offering moments of beauty and introspection, even if it doesn't fully live up to the fanfare.
2024-12-01

G

Geronimo1967
"Prabha" (Kani Kusruti) is a nurse in a busy Mumbai hospital who shares her tiny apartment with the usually skint "Anu" (Divya Prabha). We quickly learn that she is married but her husband left her some while ago to work in Germany and she hasn't heard from him in over a year. "Anu", on the other hand, has a different emotional problem. She has fallen in love with a young Muslim man "Shiaz" (Hridhu Haroon) but knows full well that neither her colleagues nor her family will ever permit such a relationship, let alone any marriage - so perhaps elopement is their only solution. Meantime, whilst these women deal with their own domestic issues, their friend "Parvaty" (Chhaya Kadam) is facing eviction from her home as the developers want to move in. Their threats have given way to more practical action as her electricity has been disconnected. In the face of this, she decides it's time to return to her ocean-side village where at least she has her own home. Sympathetic to her plight, the two friends agree to accompany her and it's whilst there that we discover through conversation and flash-backs a little of just how each woman found themselves where they are now, and we take a look at what opportunities might present themselves for their futures. It's a delicately presented story this, set amongst the hustle and bustle of a city that never stops. These women care about others all the time, but are gradually becoming aware that they also have to start caring more about themselves - and for "Prabha" who has attracted the interest of the kindly "Dr. Manoj" (Azees Nedumangad) she has to decide whether to remain faithful to her past or look to what might be next. There's some solid photography throughout capturing both the lively (and frequently rainy) urban busyness as well as the beauty of the water and the ancient peaceful symbolism carved in the caves, and the whole thrust of the narrative illustrates poignantly the choices (or lack of them) that these women can make in a society where conformity is the order of the day. It can be quite fun at times too, these women are not sackcloth and ashes characters, but there's still a potent message that creates an engaging and characterful study that's well worth a couple of hours.
2024-11-30

Recommendations

Not Here to Be Loved
3.4

Not Here to Be Loved

2005-10-12

Jean-Claude Delsart, a 50 years-old bailiff, with his worn-out smile and heart, abandoned a long tim

Taxi Driver
4

Taxi Driver

1976-02-09

Suffering from insomnia, disturbed loner Travis Bickle takes a job as a New York City cabbie, haunti

The Secret Life of Words
3.5

The Secret Life of Words

2005-12-15

A solitary nurse bonds with a badly burned patient who survived an accident on an oil rig.

Pearl Harbor
3.5

Pearl Harbor

2001-05-21

The lifelong friendship between Rafe McCawley and Danny Walker is put to the ultimate test when the

Meet the Fockers
3.1

Meet the Fockers

2004-12-22

Hard-to-crack ex-CIA man Jack Byrnes and his wife Dina head for the warmer climes of Florida to meet

Together
3.5

Together

2000-08-25

Elisabeth leaves her abusive and drunken husband Rolf, and goes to live with her brother, Göran. The

The White Sound
3.5

The White Sound

2001-12-31

Lukas, a young schizophrenic man, has to deal with a new town, a new relationship, and the paranoia

Head-On
3.7

Head-On

2004-03-11

With the intention to break free from the strict familial restrictions, a suicidal young woman sets

Notting Hill
3.6

Notting Hill

1999-05-21

London bookstore owner William Thacker's quiet life turns upside down when a chance encounter with f

One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
4.2

One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest

1975-11-19

A petty criminal fakes insanity to serve his sentence in a mental ward rather than prison. He soon f

Doctor Zhivago
3.8

Doctor Zhivago

1965-12-22

The life of a Russian physician and poet who, although married to another, falls in love with a poli

Winter Sleepers
3.5

Winter Sleepers

1997-10-30

Young blonde translator Rebecca lives with her boyfriend ski instructor Marco in a mountain villa ow

Persona
4

Persona

1966-10-18

A young nurse, Alma, is put in charge of Elisabeth Vogler: an actress who is seemingly healthy in al

Himeyuri
0

Himeyuri

2012-06-23

The 30-minute film centers around a group of high school students who became nurses called Himeyuri

The Spanish Apartment
3.6

The Spanish Apartment

2002-06-19

A strait-laced French student moves into an apartment in Barcelona with a cast of six other characte

Learning to Lie
3.2

Learning to Lie

2003-07-02

18-year-old school boy Helmut falls in love with fellow pupil Britta. He starts working for a Peace

Strange Justice
2.3

Strange Justice

1932-10-07

Socialite banker Henry Judson maintains his extravagant lifestyle by embezzling from his bank, but i

What You Believe
0

What You Believe

2018-02-08

Jun-woo and Ji-ho went to an improvised drinking at a motel. Jun-woo is dating Dae-woong and met him

Burning
3.7

Burning

2018-05-17

Deliveryman Jong-su is out on a job when he runs into Hae-mi, a girl who once lived in his neighborh

Merry Christmas, Mr. Lawrence
3.6

Merry Christmas, Mr. Lawrence

1983-05-28

Island of Java, 1942, during World War II. British Major Jack Celliers arrives at a Japanese prison