Back home

Agnes of God

133 votes

Producing House

When a dead newborn is found, wrapped in bloody sheets, in the bedroom wastebasket of a young novice, psychiatrist Martha Livingston is called in to determine if the seemingly innocent novice, who knows nothing of sex or birth, is competent enough to stand trial for the murder of the baby.

movie

Status: Released

Released Date: 1985-09-13

Runtime: 98 mins

Director: Norman Jewison

Spoken language: Latin, English, Français

Genres: Drama, Mystery

Original title: Agnes of God

Production Companies: Columbia Pictures

Production Countries: United States of America

Reviews

W

Wuchak
_**Melodramatic havoc at a rural Canadian Convent with Jane Fonda, Anne Bancroft and Meg Tilly**_ After a bloody scandal at a Convent outside Montreal, a court-appointed psychiatrist (Jane Fonda) investigates to determine if a devout, but hysterical young woman (Meg Tilly) is fit to stand trial, but she’ll have to get past the intractable Mother Superior (Anne Bancroft) to find the truth. "Agnes of God" (1985) is a psychological drama revolving around a Convent with a few scenes of Montreal thrown in. What we have here is a mystery: Was the innocent & naïve Agnes (1) impregnated by God, (2) by some dude in the barn or wherever, or (3) a kind of spontaneous cloning or twinning. Concerning that last possibility: There are supposedly nine documented virgin births on record and the offspring were all girls who looked like their mothers. The idea that Agnes calls the baby "she” augments this possibility, plus the fact that she seemingly has enough faith to put holes in her hand, aka stigmata, why couldn't she split a cell in her womb? I’m not going to say what conclusion the ambiguous film points to, if any. “Stigmata” (1999) covers some of the same ground but is from the thriller/horror genre whereas “Agnes of God” is more mundane. “Stigmata” is all-around more compelling while “Agnes” is rather one-dimensional with women constantly confronting each other with a lot of screaming and crying. Yes, there are heavy reasons for these emotional dialogues, and those reasons are interesting to explore, but the story just wasn’t gripping for me. Too bad, because Fonda, Bancroft and Tilly bend over backwards to pull it off. While the movie didn’t really work for me, it’s a passionate and noble effort centering around faith, logic and ultimate reality (truth). And I have no doubt it has a cult following. Give it a try if the themes trip your trigger, but you’ll probably be disappointed. The movie runs 1 hour, 38 minutes, and was shot in Rockwood & Toronto, Ontario, with establishing shots of Montreal. GRADE: C
2020-11-24

Recommendations

This Greedy Old Skin
0

This Greedy Old Skin

1960-09-18

A kind of modern dress "Donzoko" "The Lower Depths", about slum life in Osaka, where a greedy widow

Exiled in America
1.5

Exiled in America

1992-11-04

A Central American revolutionary is captured and tortured by government forces. He escapes and flees

West Side Story
3.6

West Side Story

1961-12-13

In Manhattan’s Upper West Side, rival gangs of Polish-Americans and newly arrived Puerto Ricans clas

The Story of Adèle H.
3.5

The Story of Adèle H.

1975-10-08

In the 19th century a mysterious woman named Adele H. crosses the ocean, from Europe to North Americ

Rent
3.4

Rent

2005-11-17

In New York City's gritty East Village, a group of bohemians strive for success and acceptance while

In the Name of the Father
3.9

In the Name of the Father

1993-12-12

A small-time Belfast thief, Gerry Conlon, is wrongly convicted of an IRA bombing in London, along wi

The Reader
3.8

The Reader

2008-12-10

The story of Michael Berg, a German lawyer who, as a teenager in the late 1950s, had an affair with

Stay
3.3

Stay

2005-09-24

Psychiatrist Sam Foster has a new patient, Henry Letham, who claims to be suicidal. In trying to dia

The Magdalene Sisters
3.7

The Magdalene Sisters

2002-08-30

Three young Irish women struggle to maintain their spirits while they endure dehumanizing abuse as i

Dark Habits
3.3

Dark Habits

1983-10-03

After her drug pusher boyfriend overdoses on heroin, a cabaret singer finds refuge from the authorit

Danton
3.4

Danton

1983-01-12

Danton and Robespierre were close friends and fought together in the French Revolution, but by 1793

Who We Are Now
2.8

Who We Are Now

2018-05-25

Recently released from prison, Beth is working with her public defender to get her son back from her

Ordinary Tenderness
4.8

Ordinary Tenderness

1973-04-04

A lonely woman spends the winter isolated and reminiscing about the past as she waits for her husban

Real Lies
2.5

Real Lies

2014-07-09

Marco Valois wants to direct a serious movie inspired by the life of a soldier living with post-trau

Queen Kelly
3.2

Queen Kelly

1932-10-18

A prince betrothed to a mad queen falls in love with an orphan girl from a convent.

Five Star Final
3.3

Five Star Final

1931-09-26

Searching for headlines at any cost, an unscrupulous newspaper owner forces his editor to print a se

The Nun
3.5

The Nun

1967-07-26

In eighteenth-century France, a girl is forced against her will to take vows as a nun. Three mothers

Girls Town
1.7

Girls Town

1959-10-05

Chip is killed accidentally while trying to rape a blonde girl, who runs. Silver becomes the number

Dangerous Love Affairs
3.2

Dangerous Love Affairs

1959-09-09

Juliette Merteuil and Valmont is a sophisticated couple, always looking for fun and excitement. Both

Separate Tables
3.5

Separate Tables

1958-12-18

The lives of a disparate group of unfulfilled people converge at a small, seaside English hotel in t