Back home

The Physician

1139 votes

Producing House

England, 1021. Rob Cole, a boy born in a miserable mining town, swears to become a physician and vanquish disease and death. His harsh path of many years, a quest for knowledge besieged by countless challenges and sacrifices, leads him to the remote Isfahan, in Persia, where he meets Ibn Sina, the greatest healer of his time.

movie

Status: Released

Released Date: 2013-12-25

Runtime: 155 mins

Director: Philipp Stölzl

Spoken language: English

Genres: Adventure, Drama, History

Original title: The Physician

Production Companies: Pixomondo, UFA Cinema, CinePostproduction, Cine Mobil, ARD, ARD Degeto

Production Countries: Germany

Reviews

F

FilipeManuelNeto
**It's a good movie, it entertains its audience well, but it's riddled with small historical errors that could easily have been corrected.** Films about medieval times are always nice to watch, especially for me, who have a great affection for this historical period, about which I did a specialization as a historian. Unfortunately, and as happens regularly, this movie is full of mistakes. The script is quite good, from an entertainment point of view: an English orphan who is raised and trained by an itinerant barber acquires a great fascination for medicine and for the ability to cure illnesses and physical ailments. However, he is aware that he knows very little, and that his master knows even less, and this awareness becomes clearer when he lives with Jewish doctors who learned his art in the East. So he decides to disguise himself as a Jew and travel to Persia in order to be admitted as a pupil of a master physician, Ibn Sina. For those who don't know, the film is partly based on real facts and characters: Ibn Sina, for example, really existed and entered the history of medicine with his Westernized name: Avicenna. It is also true that the Arabs had, during this period (the so-called Year A Thousand), a much more advanced scientific knowledge than the Christians, and the Jews, who had a certain ease in circulating between the two worlds (East and West), ended up developing a particular vocation for science and medicine, which was later used in the West, especially in times of greater religious tolerance. Unfortunately, many things in the film (particularly the details) don't make sense: it would be a bit difficult for a Christian without much education to disguise himself as a Jew without being recognized and “unmasked”, nor would it be so easy to make a journey from the British Isles to the heart of Persia, although it would not be impossible. It would be impossible, however, to see the Persians of the year 1000 celebrating something with fireworks, since this technology only reached that culture two hundred years later. Modern notions of sorcery and necromancy would also only emerge from the 13th century onwards, and the Church never burned anyone, it declared the defendant a heretic and handed him over to civil justice, which (that one) could burn him or not. Even more egregious was the mistake of including in the film an epidemic of bubonic plague before the 14th century, when the disease historically appeared. And even though the Shah did exist, and the Seljuks were indeed a threat in the region during the time period depicted, we would never have seen Muslims prostrate themselves to the Shah because they simply won't. There are still other errors: the Tower of London, which appears at the end of the film, was only built a hundred years later and would not have the appearance of the current building until, at least, the 16th century. Don't get me wrong, the movie is worth it even with these problems. What we have to understand is that this is not a documentary and things were not exactly as they are portrayed. Thomas Payne is quite good in the lead role and does a good job as an actor, even if he is sometimes overshadowed by the impressive and charismatic performances of colleagues like Stellan Skarsgard or Ben Kingsley, two actors who are in excellent shape and who give us truly committed performances. and interesting. Emma Ribgy has also done a good job, but has relatively little to do. Technically, the film has good cinematography and good sets and costumes. They're not especially accurate from a historical point of view, but they're aesthetically well done. The CGI is reasonably good and works well, if not very realistic. The soundtrack didn't particularly convince or please me, but the visual and sound effects are good. The pace is also quite good, and despite the film being relatively long, you hardly feel the time passing.
2022-12-31

Recommendations

Prison Break
2.9

Prison Break

2017-04-12

One late night in June 1942, Sakuma Seitaro dangles from the frame of a skylight in an isolation cel

Nelly Rapp – Monster Agent
2.8

Nelly Rapp – Monster Agent

2020-10-23

Nelly and her dog London are about to spend autumn break with her uncle Hannibal. Soon she noticed t

Closely Watched Trains
3.6

Closely Watched Trains

1966-11-18

At a village railway station in occupied Czechoslovakia, a bumbling dispatcher’s apprentice longs to

Cruel Intentions
3.4

Cruel Intentions

1999-03-05

Slaking a thirst for dangerous games, Kathryn challenges her stepbrother, Sebastian, to deflower the

Rosemary's Baby
3.9

Rosemary's Baby

1968-06-12

A young couple, Rosemary and Guy, moves into an infamous New York apartment building, known by frigh

Shrek
3.9

Shrek

2001-05-18

It ain't easy bein' green -- especially if you're a likable (albeit smelly) ogre named Shrek. On a m

Animal Farm
2.9

Animal Farm

1999-10-03

Animals on a farm lead a revolution against the farmers to put their destiny in their own hands. How

JFK
3.8

JFK

1991-12-20

Follows the investigation into the assassination of President John F. Kennedy led by New Orleans dis

The Bridge on the River Kwai
3.9

The Bridge on the River Kwai

1957-10-11

The classic story of English POWs in Burma forced to build a bridge to aid the war effort of their J

Dune
3.1

Dune

1984-12-14

In the year 10,191, the most precious substance in the universe is the spice Melange. The spice exte

2046
3.6

2046

2004-10-20

Women enter and exit a science fiction author's life over the course of a few years after the author

Black Hawk Down
3.7

Black Hawk Down

2001-12-28

When U.S. Rangers and an elite Delta Force team attempt to kidnap two underlings of a Somali warlord

Dangerous Liaisons
3.6

Dangerous Liaisons

1988-12-21

In 18th century France, Marquise de Merteuil asks her ex-lover Vicomte de Valmont to seduce the futu

Sliver
2.8

Sliver

1993-05-21

A woman moves into a Manhattan apartment, where she learns that the previous tenant's life ended und

Planet of the Apes
3.8

Planet of the Apes

1968-02-07

Astronaut Taylor crash lands on a distant planet ruled by apes who use a primitive race of humans fo

The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry
3.2

The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry

2022-10-07

This comical love story follows the story of A.J. Fikry, whose life is not at all what he expected i

What's Eating Gilbert Grape
3.8

What's Eating Gilbert Grape

1993-12-17

Gilbert Grape is a small-town young man with a lot of responsibility. Chief among his concerns are h

Primal Fear
3.8

Primal Fear

1996-03-06

Defense attorney Martin Vail takes on jobs for money and prestige rather than any sense of the great

Jules and Jim
3.8

Jules and Jim

1962-01-23

In the carefree days before World War I, introverted Austrian author Jules strikes up a friendship w

La Chinoise
3.5

La Chinoise

1967-08-30

A small group of French students are studying Mao, trying to find out their position in the world an